Honestly? I’m tired of hearing about this debate. Every marketing person acts like you have to pick a side and stick with it forever. Meanwhile, you’re just trying to keep your shop running and get more people through the door.
Here’s the thing – your customers don’t care about your marketing strategy. They just want to find what they need. Some people still grab the local paper with their coffee. Others live on their phones. Most do both, depending on their mood and what they’re looking for.
I’ve seen shop owners stress about this decision way too much. They read articles, attend seminars, and tie themselves in knots trying to figure out the “right” answer. But there isn’t one right answer that works for everyone.
Large Format Printing
Your Customers Aren’t Marketing Experts
People don’t wake up thinking about where they want to see ads today. They wake up with stuff to do and problems to solve. Maybe they need their car fixed, or they want to try a new restaurant, or they’re looking for a birthday gift.
How they go about finding these things depends on who they are and what’s happening in their life. Your regular customer who’s been coming in for years probably found you completely differently than the new customer who walked in yesterday.
Some people discover businesses by accident. They’re driving around, notice your sign, and file it away for later. Others are deliberate researchers who compare options online before making any decision. Both types spend money – they just need different approaches.
The trick is figuring out which type of customer you’re trying to reach, and then meeting them where they already are.
Digital Stuff That Actually Matters
Online marketing works because people are already online looking for businesses like yours. When someone googles “bike repair near me,” you want to show up in those results. It’s that simple.
The targeting thing is pretty useful too. Instead of paying to reach everyone in your town, you can focus on people who actually care about what you sell. A pet store can target pet owners. A gym can target people interested in fitness. It saves money and gets better results.
Social media is weird but it works. People follow businesses they like, even when they’re not buying anything right now. Then when they need something, your business is already familiar to them. It’s like staying in touch with customers without being pushy about it.
You can also change things fast when they’re not working. If an ad sucks, you can fix it today instead of waiting until next month’s newspaper deadline.
The Numbers Don’t Lie
With digital marketing, you can see exactly what’s happening. How many people saw your ad? How many clicked on it? How many called your shop? These numbers help you figure out what’s working and what’s not.
This is huge for small businesses because you can’t afford to waste money on advertising that doesn’t work. When you can track everything, you can stop doing the stuff that’s not bringing in customers and do more of what is.
Why Print Advertising Still Works
Local newspapers and magazines work because people read them when they’re relaxed. They’re sitting with their coffee, not rushing around or multitasking. Your ad has their full attention for at least a few seconds.
Physical stuff also sticks around. A postcard might sit on someone’s kitchen table for weeks. Every time they see it, they think about your business. Digital ads disappear forever once someone scrolls past them.
Being in the local paper also makes you look legit. When people see your business featured alongside local news and community events, it signals that you’re part of the neighborhood, not some random company trying to make a quick buck.
Stop Overthinking This
The best approach is probably doing a little of both, but leaning heavier toward whatever brings in more customers. And the only way to figure that out is by trying things and paying attention to what happens.
Ask new customers how they heard about you. Keep track of their answers. If most people mention online searches, put more money into digital stuff. If they’re finding you through local publications, keep investing in print ads.
Your neighbor’s business might get amazing results from Facebook ads while you do better with newspaper advertising. That’s fine. Every business is different, and every customer base is different.
Start Small and See What Happens
Try both things on a small scale before committing big money. Run a cheap Facebook ad for a month. Put a small ad in the local paper. See which one brings in more customers who actually spend money.
Don’t try to be too clever with your first attempts. Just tell people what you sell and how to reach you. Save the creative stuff for later, after you know what actually works.
The whole point is finding reliable ways to connect with people who want what you’re selling. Maybe that happens through their phone, maybe through the local paper, maybe through both. Let your actual results guide your decisions instead of following what everyone else is doing.
Focus on What Actually Works
Every business is different. What works great for the coffee shop down the street might be terrible for your auto repair shop. What brings customers to a boutique in Princeton might not work for a hardware store in Toms River.
Pay attention to your own customers instead of copying other people’s strategies. Notice how they talk when they call. Ask questions about how they found you. Watch what information they already have when they walk in.
Your customers will tell you what kind of marketing they respond to if you listen. Some people do all their research online before buying anything. Others trust recommendations from local sources. Both groups spend money – they just need different approaches to feel comfortable choosing your business.
The goal isn’t to win some marketing competition. It’s to connect with people who need what you offer in a way that feels natural to them. Sometimes that’s digital, sometimes it’s print, and usually it’s some combination that reflects how real people actually live their lives.
